Case Analysis: Fairstar Heavy Transport NV v Adkins & Anor
Fairstar Heavy Transport NV v Adkins & Anor
Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
July 19th, 2013
Mr Justice Edwards-Stuart
Facts
Following the termination of the appointment of Fairstar Heavy Transport NV's Chief Executive Officer, Philip Adkins, the appellant company sought access for the retrieval of emails relating to its business affairs, rendering them essential for the future conduct of the business. During his tenure, Adkins had arranged for all the business emails to be automatically forwarded to his personal email address, deleting their copies from Fairstar's server. Consequently, Fairstar no longer possessed many emails concerning its business operation.
Adkins refused to provide access and therefore Fairstar commenced proceedings seeking inspection and copying of the emails, claiming it had a proprietary right to access the contents of the emails -rather than relying upon contractual or fiduciary duties.
Preliminary issue
The parties agreed that the following issue should be determined:
"Does Fairstar have an enforceable proprietary claim to the content of the emails held by Mr Atkins (and/or Claranet) in so far as they were received or sent by Mr Adkins acting on behalf of Fairstar?"
This claim acts as an assertion by Fairstar of a proprietary right to the content of emails relating to Fairstar's business. It is argued on the appeal that Fairstar was and is entitled, as principal, to inspect and copy its business correspondence, which is held by its agent in whatever form, whether hard copy or electronic.
The appellants sought to enact their right to the content of the emails, rather than claiming a breach of contract committed by Mr Adkins in his management of Fairstar's affairs as its CEO.
Broadly, an issue was raised regarding whether a company can obtain access to business emails, on the grounds of a proprietary claim, held by a former employee or agent where no recognised property right in the information itself exists -since information does not constitute property capable of being owned.
Legal issue:
(1) Whether English law recognises an enforceable proprietary right in the information contained within business emails
(2) Whether information contained in an email can constitute property
(3) Whether a principal may obtain access to business communications held by a former agent
(4) Whether traditional agency principles apply equally to modern forms of electronic communication.
Decisions
High Court (Edward Stuart J):
Edward Stuart J held that Fairstar's claim failed.
The court concluded that the content of the emails to which Fairstar claimed a proprietary right to amounted to "information" rather than property. Existing authorities suggested that English law does not generally recognise a proprietary right in information as such. Consequently, Fairstar failed to establish the enforceable proprietary claim upon which the action had been based.
The judge rejected that the argument that the contents of the emails should be treated as a form of property. Since Fairstar's entire case depended upon establishing a proprietary right in the contents of emails, the claim was therefore dismissed.
Court of Appeal:
Unanimously allowed the appeal.
Lord Justice Mummery held that the parties had become distracted by the question of whether there was "property" in the contents of the emails. The preliminary issue had introduced an unnecessary complication because the dispute could be resolved without determining whether information itself constituted property.
Instead, the Court focused upon the legal consequences of the principal-agent relationship between Fairstar and Adkins.
The Court held that:
- A principal is generally entitled to require its agent to produce documents relating to the principal's affairs
- This entitlement survives termination of the agency relationship
- Emails should be treated as documents for these purposes
- The fact that information is stored electronically rather than on paper does not alter the principal's rights.
Accordingly, Fairstar was entitled to inspect and copy the emails irrespective of whether the information within them could be classified as property.
Arguments of the parties
Fairstar:
(a) The decision of the judge should be reversed on the ground that "a principal is entitled to inspect and copy correspondence held by its agent" regardless of whether it exists in paper or electronic form
(b) The location and format of the emails should not affect access rights
(c) It would be irrational if a principal could inspect a printed email but not the same email merely if it were stored electronically
(d) The rights asserted arose from the agency relation ship rather than from any allegation of wrongdoing by Adkins.
Mr Adkins:
(a) The emails had been lawfully sent and received in the course of business
(b) The claim was fundamentally misconceived because it was based upon ownership of information
(c) Information is not generally recognised as property under English law
(d) The emails were neither alleged to be confidential nor protected by intellectual property rights
(e) Fairstar was attempting to transform a failed proprietary claim into an agency-based claim.
Ratio Decidendi
A principal is entitled, as an incident of the agency relationship, to inspect and copy business emails held by a former agent, where those emails regard the principal's affairs. This right exists independent of a proprietary claim to the information contained within the emails.
Obiter Dicta
The Court indicated that it would be unwise to adopt a broad proposition that information can never constitute property, as, different forms of information may raise different legal considerations. Thus, the Court avoided deciding that wider issue.
Significance of the decision
I believe that this case is significant as it demonstrates the courts' willingness to apply legal principles which have already been established, to modern cases involving modern technologies, without having to establish new proprietary rights.
I find it notable that rather than recognising ownership of digital information, the Court relied upon traditional agency law in order to achieve a practical result which, as a result, preserved consistency whilst also ensuring that legal principles remain adaptable to technological developments.
Analysis
- The Court of Appeal's reasoning was persuasive and effective as they successfully adapted orthodox principles to new circumstances involving technological developments, without making controversial statements which would give rise to significant implications within commercial law, confidentiality and intellectual property law.
- The judgment has been greatly criticised for leaving the broader question, of whether digital information can ever constitute property, unresolved. The court expressly refused to address this issue, consequently allowing uncertainty to remain within English law in regards to digital information and its proprietary status.
- While simultaneously exposing a broader conceptual problem in modern commercial law in that information has immense economic value, the legal basis upon which it is controlled remains unclear, with those involved relying upon agency, confidence, contract, and/or intellectual property rights rather than ownership itself.
What the case established
The case of Fairstar Heavy Transport NV v Adkins & Anor established that a company does not need to prove ownership of the information contained within business emails in order to gain access to them. Where a principal- agent relationship exists, a principal may require a former agent to provide access to business emails relating to the principal's affairs, regardless of whether those emails are stored electronically or in paper form.
Fairstar Heavy Transport NV v Adkins & Anor , (July 19, 2013). https://uk.westlaw.com/Document/I2ABBEA00AF8B11E3A154C3480D531AE8/View/FullText.html
Comments