top of page
Search

What disciplinary sanctions should teachers be allowed to use?

Ioanna Christodoulatou
Jun 6
3 min read

Disciplinary sanctions with regards to the educational system are forms of penalty imposed by teachers on parents and students. Under the democratically elected government of the UK, teachers have been granted the authority to punish students and parents who do not follow the rules. In this essay I will argue that a progressively punitive and proportionate method should be imposed whereby the students’ actions addressed proportionate to their significance of their actions or rather, (inactions), with the purpose of support and an opportunity for self-development rather than retribution. 


My belief is that children should be persuaded and taught to act, rather than punished. This is because with punishment comes resentment and may be followed by further acts of rebellion. A study conducted by the university of Oxford has found a link between children’s environment of upbringing and their conduct, holding the parents/guardians accountable for a child’s misconduct -which is why punishing the child will only ‘treat the symptom’ rather than address the cause. Consequently, teachers must impose sanctions persuasively through discussions and in non-violent manners. Although discussing during school-hours may be seen as a punishment by the student as they may be losing their break-time, it should be made clear to them that the aim is not punishment but rather reflection, support, and an effort for improvement and self-development. In the case that the child largely refuses to have the discussion during a break-time, an alternative solution must be agreed between the teacher and student, at a time convenient for both, in order to ensure that the child does not view this as a punishment, to primarily discuss the issue. In doing so, the student is made to understand their fault and what is right, rather than simply being punished. These discussions are necessary in order to prevent the recurring event of disorderly conduct and disrespect in the future. However, it is important to consider that persuasion alone will not necessarily lead to change. A student who refuses to listen must understand that rules cannot be ignored. School is a warm-up for life. Thus, teacher approaches when addressing issues with students must not be considered sanctions but rather as a non-punitive method of providing the child with guidance and support.


In order for it to be ensured that a child understands that rules cannot be ignored, the consequences for breaking them must be clear, consistent and proportionate, similar to law and the resolution of cases themselves. As Beccaria states, the effectiveness of a sanction depends less on severity and rather on its certainty and proportionality. Therefore, it is necessary that a progressive system of sanctions is created whereby the sanction matches the significance of the student’s actions or inactions. Notably, there must be no physical punishment, no verbal or emotional abuse and no threats. Students must be taught to respect the rules not fear the individuals imposing them.  A first-offence may be addressed through a discussion, which can be followed by a loss of free time, a parent-teacher meeting and suspension as a last resort for serious or recurring misconduct. Utilitarianists like Jeremy Bentham may argue that harsh sanctions like the removal of a disruptive student must be imposed. The sacrifice of one child will be in the interests and benefit of another 25 students. Moreover, it must be considered that teachers with large classrooms may not have time to have discussion with every disruptive student. However, I believe it is important to consider that although firmness is essential, harsh sanctions risk pushing an already struggling student out of education altogether, simply removing the problem from the school rather than solving it. It may achieve quiet and order in the classroom but it does not achieve respect for the rules. Today’s students are tomorrow’s future citizens. Thus, the teachers must prepare students to be responsible for later life through mimicking the legal system where misconduct is addressed; demanding respect for and compliance of the rules imposed. 


Conclusively, teachers must address a lack of discipline through non-punitive methods. I consider that explaining and persuading students that they must follow rules as they are imposed in their favour.  

 

 

 

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Drop Us a Message, We Value Your Feedback

© 2025 by My Legal Journal. All rights reserved.

bottom of page